How to keep score on election night

 

This map and the explanations may help you to follow this historic election, hour by hour.   Print this out in color, if possible. If you'd like to see a number of predictive models, click here.

 

Presidential Map

This map has Obama’s likely wins in blue and McCain’s likely wins in red. Toss-up states are in gray. I've defined toss-ups the same way as Real Clear Politics does, except that I've also included two states in which Obama has less than 51 percent, according to polls: New Mexico and Nevada; I have kept Colorado blue because the latest poll has him above 51%. If most of the undecided voters break to McCain, a real possibility, Obama should still get most or all of the blue states on the below map. This map gives Obama 268 electoral votes. If Obama takes any of the 12 toss-up states while keeping his own blue states, he wins (one needs 270 electoral votes to win). If McCain sweeps the red states and captures all of the toss-ups, he wins. This all shows that Obama is heavily favored, but the only poll that counts is the election. That’s why we’re watching television and logging on Tuesday night.

The 12 toss-ups are also listed below in bold, along with their closing times.  The networks typically call states that aren't close a couple of minutes after the polls close. Note, however, that record voter turnout could keep polls open later.  

Toss-up states, in order of closing time (all times are ET)
Score for yourself:      Obama McCain
Indiana (6-7 p.m.)       _____ _____
Georgia  (7 p.m.)         _____ _____
Virginia  (7 p.m.)         _____ _____
N. C. (7:30 p.m.)        _____ _____
Ohio (7:30 p.m.)         _____ _____ 
Florida (8 p.m.)           _____ _____
Missouri (8 p.m.)         _____ _____
New Mexico (9 p.m.)    _____ _____
Arizona (9 p.m.)          _____ _____
Montana (10 p.m.)       _____ _____
North Dakota (10 p.m.) _____ _____
Nevada  (10 p.m.)       _____ _____
Obama likely needs one of these states, McCain all 12 (see additional notes, below)

The House
As you may know, the entire House is up for election every two years. Because there are so many seats, it's difficult to keep track. The conventional wisdom is that the Democrats, who have a sizeable majority, will gain many seats. You can read more here.  The Senate, which elects its members for six years (roughly a third of its body is up for election every two years), is more interesting this time around. Here's why:

Senate List

The Senate Democrats, who now have a 51-49 majority (including the two independents who caucus with them), will most likely end the evening with 57 to 60 seats. If the number of Democrats is 60 or higher (unlikely but possible), the Democrats will have a near-lock on the Senate, based on Senate rules. Right now, 35 seats are up for grabs. This might sound like you’ll need to follow a lot of races, but here’s a simple way of looking at it: Most of these are not really competitive; like in the Presidential race, 12 Senate races are important to watch. They all have Republican incumbents. Four, listed below, are likely pickups for the Democrats and these would most likely give them 55 seats. There are eight more close races worth watching, all possible pickups for Democrats, listed below.  

 

Republican Senate seats in Play    Probable # of Dem. Seats

 

Likely for Dems to pickup Rep. seats:

New Hampshire (7 p.m.)                  52

Virginia (7 p.m.)                             53

Colorado (9 p.m.)                           54

New Mexico (9 p.m.)                       55

 

Toss-ups

Kentucky (6-7 p.m.)                        Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Georgia (7 p.m.)                             Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

North Carolina (7:30 p.m.)                Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Mississippi (8 p.m.)                          Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Minnesota (9 p.m.)                          Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Texas (9 p.m.)                                Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Oregon (11 p.m.)                             Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

Alaska (midnight)                             Fill it in yourself: if the Dem wins add 1 to 55______

 

For more on Senate races see http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/ and http://www.electoral-vote.com/ and click on “Senate” at the top of the page.

 

Important notes about the presidential and senate races

 

Closing times (ET) Closing states (presidential toss-ups in bold) Presidential  notes Senate
6 p.m. (some polls in these states stay open until 7 p.m.) Indiana (toss up), Kentucky
 
Indiana is a toss up, but McCain is favored. If Obama wins, it could foreshadow a huge Obama victory . Bush won the state by 20 points in 2004, and no Democratic presidential candidate has won the state since 1964. The Democrats start the night with 51 seats (including two independents). The first of 12 races is Kentucky. Can Lunsford (D) beat McConnell? If so add 1 to the Dems' 55 seats (see the score sheet, above)
7 p.m. Georgia (toss up), New Hampshire, South Carolina, Vermont, Virginia (toss up) Some say that we might know the winner by now (that’s if Indiana, Georgia or Virginia gObama);  early voting appears to be going Obama's way in Georgia. But Pennsylvania and New Hampshire, closing at 8 p.m., are two big keys to a potential McCain upset. Georgia: competitive. New Hampshire, Virginia: Dems should win.  
7:30 p.m. North Carolina, Ohio (both toss ups), West Virginia   These closings are crucial: McCain probably can’t win without Ohio and N.C.; early voting appears to be going Obama's way in N.C. North Carolina: (Can Democratic Hagan beat incumbent Dole?
8 p.m. Alabama, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida (toss up), Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri (toss up), New Jersey, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Arkansas (8:30 p.m.) McCain needs Florida and Missouri; If Obama loses Pennsylvania, it could give McCain supporters hope for an upset.  Mississippi: The Dems taking this red red state would be huge, but it's looking unlikely.
9 p.m. Arizona (toss up), Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Mexico (toss up), New York, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Texas, Wisconsin, Wyoming Colorado, Minnesota, New Mexico, and Wisconsin are close (Col., N.M. went to Bush in ’04). Even McCain's home state, Arizona, is close, and it's now a toss-up. The consensus is that Colorado will go to Obama, but early voting has been more evenly split between the parties (compared with say, Georgia) and may signal a McCain victory in Colorado. Colorado, Minnesota, New Mexico, Texas: Democratic Udall brothers should win in Colorado and New Mexico. Can comedian Al Franken win in Minn.? Texas, too, is a possible Senate pick up for the Dems.
10 p.m. Iowa, Montana, Nevada, North Dakota (three toss ups), Utah Iowa should be another pickup for Obama; Bush won it in 2004. Nevada is the must-win toss-up here, but watch North Dakota and Montana, too. McCain has been advertising in those two states, too, against all expectations. Oregon: Yet another probable win over a Republican incumbent.
11 p.m. California, Hawaii, Idaho, Oregon, Washington If it’s still close at 11 p.m., Obama is banking on Oregon and Washington  
Midnight Alaska   Alaska: Convicted incumbent Republican Ted Stevens might go down.

 

 

This election guide was prepared by Dave the Teacher, a journalism professor at Saint Michael's College and a political junkie.

 

If you'd like to send me a quick note about this page-- positive or negative-- you can do so here.