Professor Amy B. Werbel

                                                                        Home: 660-4918

                                                                         e-mail:  awerbel

 

Syllabus - Art 361

Art, Architecture and Material Culture of the United States

Spring, 2008

Tuesday, Thursday, 10-11:40 a.m. JEM 391

 

Texts you really should purchase: 

Marianne Doezema and Elizabeth Milroy, eds., Reading American Art

Alan Trachtenberg, Reading American Photographs

Jonathan Weinberg, Ambition and Love in Modern American Art

 

Optional texts (there will be two copies on reserve):

 

Janet C. Berlo and Ruth B. Phillips, Native North American Art

Amy Werbel, Thomas Eakins: Art, Medicine, and Sexuality in

Nineteenth-Century Philadelphia

Lisa E. Farrington, Creating Their Own Images: The History of African-American

Women Artists

David Lubin, Shooting Kennedy: JFK and the Culture of Images

Craig Whitaker, Architecture and the American Dream

 

Daily Topics and Assignments:

 

January 15     Introduction: Guiding Questions

 

January 17     Native North American Art I

                        Reading: Berlo and Phillips, 1-35

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

January 22     Native North American Art II

Reading: Berlo and Phillips, 71-105

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

January 24     Foundations of European-American Art, Architecture, and Town Planning

Reading: “The Old World and the New” 23-42, 57-67, in American Encounters (on ECollege)

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

January 29     Early Massachusetts Painting

Reading: Wayne Craven, “The Seventeenth-Century New England Mercantile Image,” and Paul Staiti, “Character and Class: The Portraits of John Singleton Copley,” in Reading American Art, 1-37

DUE TODAYQuestions, Quotes and Comments

 

January 31     Charles Willson Peale

Reading: Roger B. Stein, “Charles Willson Peale’s Expressive Design, in Reading American Art, 38-78

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

February 5     American Land and Landscape

Reading: Alan Wallach, “Thomas Cole and the Aristocracy,” in Reading American Art, 79-107

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

February 7     Slaves and Heroines

                        Reading: Joy S. Kasson, “Narratives of the Female Body: The Greek Slave” and Kirsten P. Buick, “The Ideal Works of Edmonia Lewis: Invoking and Inverting Autobiography” in Reading American Art, 163-207.

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

February 12   Lilly Martin Spencer

Reading: David Lubin, “Lilly Martin Spencer’s Domestic Genre Paintings in Antebellum America,” 159-204, in Picturing a Nation: Art and Social Change in Nineteenth-Century America (on ECollege)

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

                       

February 14   American Art History Slam I

DUE TODAY: Five-minute Presentations of

                        First Book Review

 

February 19, 21 No classes

 

February 26   Thomas Eakins I

Reading: Amy Werbel, “From Benjamin Franklin to Thomas Eakins,” in Thomas Eakins: Art, Medicine, and Sexuality in Nineteenth-Century America, 1-27

DUE TODAY: Questions, Quotes and Comments AND

Finished Book Review #1

 

February 28   Thomas Eakins II

Reading: Amy Werbel, “The Agnew Clinic, The Gross Clinic, Crucifixion, and Swimming: Dissecting Eakins’ Paintings,” in Thomas Eakins: Art, Medicine, and Sexuality in Nineteenth-Century America, 28-52

DUE TODAY: Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 4         Cassatt and Homer

                        Reading: Jules D. Prown, “Winslow Homer in His Art,” and Griselda Pollock, “Mary Cassatt: Painter of Women and Children,” 264-301, in Reading American Art

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 6         Early American Photography

                        Reading: Trachtenberg, 3-70

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 11       Civil War Photography (Town Meeting Day – vote in honor)

Reading: Trachtenberg, 71-118

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 13       Camera Work / Social Work

Reading: Trachtenberg, 164-230

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 18, 20 No Class – Break

 

March 25       African-American Women Artists

Reading: Farrington, chaps. 1-3

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

March 27       African-American Women Artists

Reading: Farrington, chaps. 4-6

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 1            Architecture and the American Dream

Reading: Craig Whitaker, “Architecture and the American Dream,” 3-31, (on E-College)

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 3            Architecture and the American Dream

Reading: Craig Whitaker, “Architecture and the American Dream,” 69-97 (on E-College)

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 8            Jackson Pollock

                        Reading: Michael Leja, “Jackson Pollock: Representing the Subconscious, 440-464, in Reading American Art

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 10          Kennedy and Visual Culture in the 1960s

Reading: David Lubin, Shooting Kennedy, 39-104

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 15          Kennedy and Visual Culture in the 1960s
Reading: David Lubin, Shooting Kennedy, 251-287

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 17          American Art History Slam II

DUE TODAY: Five-minute Presentations of

                        Second Book Review

 

April 22          Sally Mann

Reading: Weinberg, ix-2, 54-72

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 24          Collaborations

Reading: Weinberg, 179-210

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

April 29          Warhol and Basquiat

                        Reading: Weinberg, 211-241

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

May 1             Short Presentations of Final Papers

DUE TODAY:  Questions, Quotes and Comments

 

Course Requirements:

 

(2) 4-page book reviews: 13 points each = 26%

(2) 5-minute presentations of book reviews: 5 points each = 10%

(app. 20) Questions, Quotes and Comments sheets on readings: 2 points each

 up to a total of 40 points = 40%

(1)        Final Research paper and short presentation (10 pp.): 25 points = 25%

 

Questions, Quotes and Comments

Questions, Quotes and Comments sheets will be used to guide our conversation every day.  These should be no more than one-page typed, single-spaced, in 12-point font.  Each day’s QQC should demonstrate your thoughtful reflection on all the reading for the day, and contribute to productive and interesting class discussion.  When you are brainstorming your QQC, think about connections between this and previous readings and also about how this text relates to our major ‘guiding questions:’

 

  • the power and role of visual culture in American society
  • roles, conventions, and visual cues associated with gender, sexual orientation, and race
  • the formation of national identity visible in art, architecture, etc.
  • class distinctions and the role of art in perpetuating them
  • the practice of art history – what kinds of questions and methods are evident in this author’s work?

 

Fundamentally, American visual culture helps us understand who we are and how we got here – what do these readings tell you about that path?  Images and historical events that surprise you are usually especially good topics for conversation. Late QQC are not accepted because they do not contribute to class discussion

 

Book Reviews and “Slam” Presentations of Book Reviews

For each book review, you will read and critique a book about American art, architecture, and or material culture chosen in consultation with the Professor.  Your book review should be approximately 4 double-spaced pages.  Make sure to include a thesis that presents your critical assessment of the merits of the text i.e. what are its strengths and weaknesses?  What does the book teach us about American visual culture? This is a formal writing assignment so grading will take into account your focus on the topic, critical thinking about the subject matter, and also elements of style: grammar, word choice, flow between and within paragraphs, etc.  These papers are due in the correct dropbox in ECollege on the dates listed.  Be sure to work in MS Word, even if you have to type it in a lab – no Macs!!! Presentations of your review in-class should be approximately five minutes, and should discuss several images from the reviewed text.

 

Final Research Paper and Presentation

The final research paper is an opportunity for students to exercise critical thinking in the analysis and interpretation of works of art.  Students are expected to formulate an original thesis, and to support it well with trustworthy sources.  A minimum of ten published academic sources should be used in preparing these papers.  Internet websites are only permissible as sources if they are sponsored by accredited museums, universities or if they are on-line publications of academic journals.  Research should be started early, since materials often must be ordered by inter-library loan from other institutions.  Citations on long papers should be in the form of endnotes and bibliography in MLA style – this is the style used in the readings you will be doing for class.  In-text citations are not used in art history papers (pet peeve!!). 

Titles of art works discussed in your paper should always be underlined and identified as [fig. 1, 2, 3, etc.].  For example:  “Thomas Eakins’ Spinning Wheel Studies [fig. 1] is an excellent example of the artist’s use of preparatory perspectival studies.”  Zeroxed illustrations of each work you discuss should be included behind the endnotes and bibliography with corresponding identification by figure number.  These illustrations should also include artist, title, medium, date and location of the work, i.e.:

                                    [zerox of Spinning Wheel Studies ]

Fig. 3  Thomas Eakins, Spinning Wheel Studies, charcoal on paper, 1883,

            Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts

 

Your research paper presentations should be created in PowerPoint or a comparable “slide viewing” program such as ArtStor.  You should bring your presentation on a CD-Rom or USB drive, in addition to keeping a copy elsewhere (i.e. on the College server).

 

Keeping in Touch with Me:

This is important.  I read my e-mail, and check my office messages frequently every day.  Although I don’t spend much time sitting still in my office, I am happy for you to call me on my cell phone in the evenings and on weekends, and I can almost always find time to speak with students, correspond via e-mail, and/or meet with you on either campus during the day and on many evenings.

 

 

 

Presentation Scoring Sheet

Use this set of criteria when planning your presentations.

 

Component

Score and comments

 

 

ORGANIZATION:

*sets clear agenda at outset

* provides context for material in introduction

* presents information in a logical order

* sums up important points in a conclusion

 

 

 

CONTENT:

*gives overview, but also “goes deep” on

      important points

*goes beyond mere presentation of text;

      critiques author and approach

*demonstrates mastery of content

 

 

 

PRESENTATION:

*well rehearsed

*smooth transitions

*audible and clear speech

*time well used, scheduled appropriately

      (not too much or too little time)

 

 

 

 

 

FORMAL ESSAY FEEDBACK/REVISION CHECKLIST

 

Use this list to help you revise your papers before you hand them in. 

Essay Component                                                                                                         

 

CONTENT

__Assignment:  Is it addressed fully?

__Class concepts:  Are they understood and applied correctly?

__Other:

 

CRITICAL THINKING

__Thesis:  Is it explicit and arguable?

__Argument:  Is it logical?

__Evidence:  Is it sufficient, appropriate, credible?

__Analysis:  Does it show how evidence supports thesis?

__Counter-arguments:  Are they addressed, if necessary?

__Focus:  Does the essay stay on topic?

 

ESSAY STRUCTURE

__Paragraphs:  Are they organized in a deliberate and helpful way?

__Paragraphs:  Are they fully developed and appropriate in length?

__Transitions:  Do they help the reader move from thought to thought?

 

LANGUAGE CONTROL

__Style:  Is it controlled and easy to read?

__Style:  Is it appropriate to the assignment and a general academic audience?

__Language:  Are Standard Written English guidelines followed for:

                                __sentence structure/grammar

                                __word choice/usage

                                __punctuation/mechanics

                                __quotations/citations

                                __spelling